James Ng W, William Cho C and Daniel Sze MY">
Received date: January 09, 2016 Accepted date: January 29, 2016 Published date: Janaury 30, 2016
Citation: James Ng W, Cho WC, Sze D MY. The Use of Medicinal Mushroom or Herb as Effective Immunomodulatory Agent. Herb Med. 2016, 2:1. DOI: 10.21767/2472-0151.100009
Background: Medicinal mushrooms are mushrooms used with the aim for health enhancement. They have been used in traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) for thousands of years. These mushrooms and some herbal medicines have gain in popularity in recent times, largely due to a growing number of scientific studies that suggest their potential medical benefits. They are found to exert immunomodulatory effects through changes in the quantity of some specific cytokines in blood; as well as numbers and activities of distinct immune cell subsets. This article summarizes the immunomodulatory effects of two commonly consumed medicinal mushrooms (Coriolus versicolor and Ganoderma lucidum) and also three herbal medicines that have been categorized as immunomodulatory in function (Cordyceps sinensis, Astragalus membranaceus and Eleutherococcus senticosus).
Methods: A systematic search of published articles of clinical trial studies between 1985 and August 2015 was conducted in four electronic databases (EMBASE, PubMed, Scopus and Web of Science). The outcome measures included changes in the serum cytokines secretion and the number and functional activity of different immune cell populations.
Results: After a thorough literature searching of 237 relevant articles, 15 were included. Coriolus versicolor and Ganoderma lucidum showed immunomodulatory effects in both innate and adaptive immunity arms. There are only very few studies in each mushroom or herb, and unequivocal conclusions cannot be drawn. Future larger trials of randomized and placebo controlled clinical studies with laboratory investigation of changes of multiple immune populations and their subsets are needed in consistent with an evidence-based medicine approach.
Medicinal mushroom; TCM; NK cells; Dendritic cells; Cytokines; Coriolus; Ganoderma
The clinical application of single synthetic or highly purified pharmaceutical compounds for health and disease is the mainstream of Western medical practice. Pure compound offers the advantage of clear structure-function relationship of pharmaceutical activity and related potential toxicity. On the contrary, many herbal medicines contain mixtures of naturally derived compounds that the underlying clinically relevant chemicals are basically unknown, nor the related mechanisms of action and target cells.
Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) herbs have been used for more than thousands of years in historical record among China, Japan, Korea and other Asian countries. TCM has been used for augmenting the immune status for healthy people and also as adjunct with cancer treatment (surgery, radiotherapy and or chemotherapy) for cancer patients . Although TCM has been advocated for its relatively safe and potential clinical beneficial effects as in many individual cases, most evidence in the literature is predominantly that of the in vitro animal studies and laboratory experimental cellular models. In comparison, the published limited in vivo clinical studies are normally of small patient numbers, equivocal explanation of the randomization protocols and lack of placebo controls.
There is a recent trend of studying TCM in the awareness of the concepts of “multi-directional” and “network” in the context of evidence-based medicine. An important advancement is the understanding that clinically useful medicine including western pure compounds may not be restricted to the “single compound single target” theory. It is clear now that even a single compound such as Thalidomide  produces its surprising significant clinical effects to extend Myeloma patients’ overall survival by modulating diverse immunological cell populations. This multi-directional mechanism of action is also seen in a TCM compound of Arsenic Trioxide that exerts its clinical effects through interacting with multiple cells in particular through a few important immune populations . A network pharmacology approach strategy has also been purposed to approach the investigation of the effects due to the TCM usage . It is therefore logical to propose that TCM herbs, each of multiple chemical compounds, can exert their effects in multiple target cells such as the diverse immunological important populations and bring about the desirable clinical effects.
Medicinal mushrooms are defined as mushrooms used as medicinal agents. Specific immunotherapeutic properties have been characterized by more than 270 recognized mushrooms species . In this review, the two medicinal mushrooms were selected because of their reported immunological activities in the management of chronic diseases including cancer , diabetes , heart disease, and other disorders .
One of the bioactive ingredients in medicinal mushroom that relate to the multi-directional immunomodulation is now known to be “Beta-glucan”. Beta-glucans are polysaccharides found in mushrooms that are known as “biological response modifiers” because of their ability to activate the immune system . It has been documented that bioactive polysaccharides or polysaccharide–protein complexes from medicinal mushrooms enhance innate and cell-mediated immune responses and exhibit antitumor activities in humans . Several of the mushroom polysaccharide compounds have been preceded through phases I, II, and III clinical trials and are currently used extensively in Asia to treat various cancers and other diseases .
This review aims to examine the evidence of the clinical trials of two medicinal mushrooms namely Coriolus versicolor and Ganoderma lucidum . The focus is how these medicinal mushrooms affect various immunological populations. Results of three selected TCM herbs that are commonly used in cancer management for immunoregulation have also been tabulated in this review for comparison. These herbs are Cordyceps sinensis, Astragalus membranaceus, and Eleutherococcus senticosus.
Searching strategy of literature databases
The methodology searching was based on published articles between 1985 and August 2015 that were listed in the following electronic databases: EMBASE, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science. The English keywords for searching included: “Medicinal mushrooms”; “Traditional Chinese medicine”; “TCM”; “immunomodulation”; “cancer”; “carcinoma”; “tumor”; “Ganoderma lucidum ”; “Coriolus versicolor”; “Trametes versicolor”; “Cordyceps sinensis”; “Astragalus membranaceus”; “Eleuther ococcus senticosus”; “Siberian ginseng”; “dendritic cell”; “NK cell”; “natural killer cell” and “cytokine”. There was no other special limitation. In addition, the reference lists of recent reviews related to the search terms are examined.
Flowchart Figure 1 represents the searching strategy of the review. Abstracts and titles were initially screened for the relevant area and followed by full reading of the text. Selection of the final 15 articles were based on the following four inclusion criteria: (1) published as English language articles; (2) provided with full text details; (3) published as clinical trial studies; (4) the outcome measurement involved immune cells and or related products, such as natural killer (NK) cells, T cells, B cells and/or cytokine. Animal studies and in vitro studies were excluded.
After a thorough searching of the literature with an initial 237 relevant articles, 222 studies were excluded with final 15 articles [12-26] on clinical trial being selected. The measurements of the cytokine profile and immune cell subsets data from these papers were tabulated and discussed in Table 1.
|(I) 1. Coriolusversicolor||PSK (polysaccharide-krestin, protein-bound polysaccharide)||Randomized into a control group (n=15) and a PSK group (n=15)
Randomly assigned to 2 weeks’ chemoradiotherapy CRT and 4 weeks’ S-1 administration before surgery (control group), or the same CRT with 4 weeks’ PSK administration (PSK group)
Control group, take oral S-180 mg/m2/day divided into 2 daily doses
PSK group ,same dose of S-1 together with PSK 3 g/day divided into 3 daily doses, for 4 weeks
|ACytokines - NA
BCell subset - significant increase (p=0.003) of NK cell by 5% in the peripheral blood and
cytotoxic T cell counts
significant increase (p=0.005) by 153% in peri-tumour
significant increase (p=0.003) by 151%in normal mucosa
|Adenocarcinoma of middle or lowerrectum (CT3/CT4) patients (30 patients)|||
|2. Coriolusversicolor||PSK (polysaccharide-
|Patients were randomly assigned to receive either 3 g PSK plus 300 mg tegafur/uracil (UFT): (PSK group) or 300 mg UFT alone (control) orally each day for 3 months and then for immune status assessment
10 patients were allocated to the PSK group and 11 to the control group
|ACytokines – NA
1. CD 57+T cells decreased significantly(p<0.05)
2. (p>0,05) No significant difference for the absolute number of Th1 cells (IFN-ÃÂ¤-positive CD4+T cells), Th2 cells (IL-4-positive CD4+ T cells), Th1/Th2 ratio, NKT cells (CD56+T cells and CD57+ T cells), NK cells, and CD25+CD4+ T cells
|Stage III gastric cancer patients (21 patients)|||
|3. Trametesversicolor (Coriolusvesicolor)||Trametesversicolorfreeze-dried mycelia powder||Each capsule contained 500 mg of product
Each cohort comprised of 3 participants given one of three doses of Trametesvesicolor(3 g, 6 g or 9 g)
|ACytokines - NA
1. Increased lymphocyte counts at 6 and 9 g/dayand (p<0.05)
2. Increased NK cell functional activity at 6 g/day (p<0.05)
3. Dose-related increases inCD8+ T cells and CD19+B cells but not CD4+ T cells or CD16+ 56+ NK cells (p<0.05)
|Breast cancer women (11 participants recruited and 9 women completed study)|||
|(II) 1 Ganodermalucidum||Ganopoly (polysaccharide)||1,800 mg Ganopoly, 3 times daily orally before meals for 12 weeks compared with baseline
Total dose of Ganopoly per day (5,400 mg=270g fruiting body of Ganodermalucidum)
|A. Cytokine (IL-2, IL-6, IFN-ÃÂ¤) # significant increase(IL-1, TNF-a) $ significant decrease (p<0.05)
1. (mean absolute no. of CD56+cells)#and significant increase(p<0.05)
2. (mean absolute no. of CD3+, CD4+and CD8+) (p<0.05)marginal #and
3. (Total PBL count and the CD4:CD8 T cell ratios) little or no significant effect
4. (NK cell activity # (34.5% compared with 26.6% at baseline) significant increase(p<0.05)
|Advanced-stage cancer patients (with cancer origin from lung, colon, breast, liver, prostate, bladder, brain and unknown) (34 patients included but only 30 patients assessed for immune function after 12 weeks)|||
|2 Ganodermalucidum||Ganodermalucidum polysaccharides Ganopoly||A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multicenter clinical trial.
12 weeks of treatment with oral Ganopoly or placebo at a dose of 3 capsules (600 mg × 3=1,800 mg) 3 times daily before meal.
A capsule of Ganopoly (150 mg polysaccharides)=30 g fruiting body of Ganodermalucidumor total dose of 5,400 mg/day of Ganopoly=270 g/day fruiting body.
|A. Cytokine - NA
B. Cell subset
1. (Lymphocyte mitogenic reactivity to concanavalin A significant increase) #
2. CD3 % significant increaseand #
3. NK cell activity significant increase# and
4. CD4 % and CD4:CD8 ratio marginal increase#and
5. CD8 marginal reduction $and
|Advanced-stage (stage III to IV) lung cancer patients (68 cancer patients recruited and only 32 patients assessable)|||
|3 Ganodermalucidum||Ganodermalucidum extract||Double-blinded, placebo-controlled, cross-over intervention study for 4 weeks supplement with encapsulated Ganodermalucidumpreparation (1.44 g/day Ganodermalucidum; equivalent to 13.2 g/day fresh mushroom per day).||A. Cytokines-Not done
B. Cell subset (CD4:CD8 ratio) no statistical significant change
|Healthy human subjects (18 healthy adults aged 22-52 years)|||
|4 Ganodermalucidum||Water-soluble Ganodermalucidumpolysaccharides||A non-randomized open-labeled study.
1,800 mg 3 times daily=5.4 g/day orally before meals for 12 weeks.
Each capsule contained 600 mg crude extract of Ganodermalucidum, with 25% (w/w) crude polysaccharides.
Total dose of Ganodermalucidumper day (5,400 mg)=81 g fruiting body.
IL-2, IL-6 and IFN-ÃÂ¤ increased but no statistical significance whereas IL-1 and TNF-a were decreased but no statistical significance.
B. Cell subset
CD3, CD4, CD8, CD56
Non-significant change in the absolute number of lymphocytes and NK activity (p>0.05)
|Advanced-stage (Stage III to IV) colorectal cancer patients (47 patients enrolled with 41 patients assessable)|||
|5 Ganodermalucidum||Ganodermalucidumextract contained 1.89% of terpenoids and 15.8% of polysaccharides||A double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trial
2 g of the extract or placebo twice daily for 10 consecutive days
Oral doses of Ganodermalucidumextract or placebo (4 capsules each time)
1. No changes in CD4, CD8 and CD19
2. No significant change in CD56+NK cell number
|Human Normal subjects (16 volunteers with 8 males and 8 non-pregnant females)|||
|6 Ganodermalucidumcapsules||The capsules (Green Valley Ganodermalucidumcapsule) contain total extract isolated from the fruiting body of Ganodermalucidum(Leyss. ex Fr.) Karst. by boiling water and pure pores.
The ratio of total extract with spores is 70%:20% in G lucidum capsules. The main active component is polysaccharides with a ratio of more than 10% for the capsules.
|40 male football players were randomly assigned to 4 groups: control (living at sea level), LHTL1, LHTL2 and LHTL3. The three LHTL groups had stayed in normobaric hypoxic rooms for 28 days. The four groups trained together at sea level. LHTL1, LHTL2 and LHTL3 groups were provided with placebo, Ganodermalucidum.
10 capsules=2.5 g/day and Ganodermalucidum20 capsules=5.0 g/day, respectively, for 6 weeks (2 weeks baseline supplementation followed by 28 days of the treatment protocol).
|ACytokines - NA
No significant difference in number of T cells in different groups
|Male football players (40 males assigned into 4 groups)|
|7 Ganodermalucidum||Spore powder including polysaccharides, triterpenoids, alkaloids, enzymes, and proteins||A randomized, placebo controlled trial
Spore powder of Ganodermalucidum1,000 mg 3 times a day for 4 weeks
TNF-aand IL-6 were significantly lower
Mean serum TNF-α pre- and post-treatment in experimental group were 128.70 pg/mL and 71.89 pg/mL
Mean serum IL-6 pre- and post-treatment in experimental group were 62.43 pg/mL and 37.62 pg/mL
B. Cell subset – NA
|Breast cancer (stage I-IIIA) patients (48 cancer patients)|
|8. Ganodermalucidum||A randomized, double-blind, cross-over trial with placebo-controlled run-in and cross-over periods.
Treatment of 12 weeks each on Ganodermalucidumtreatment or placebo, 2 capsules twice daily.
The dosage=1·44 g Ganodermalucidumextract/day taken with two capsules (each capsule contains 360 mg extract) twice daily=13·2 g of the fresh mushroom.
|A. Cytokines – NA
B. Cell subset
No significant difference on B-lymphocytes and T helper cell counts and percentages for the treatment group.
|Hypertension and or dyslipidemia patients (26 patients recruited with final 23 evaluable subjects)|||
|(I) Cordycepssinensis||Cordycepssinensiswith low dose of cyclosporin A||A. Cytokine
No significant difference in IL-2 in the two groups.
IL-10 in the treatment group was significantly (p<0.05) higher than that in control group.
B. Cell subset – NA
|Renal transplant patients|||
|(I) Astragalusmembranaceuspolysaccharide||Injection of astragalusextract (AI)||AI 20 ml was added into 250 ml of 5% glucose solution given through intravenous dripping.
Randomly assigned into conventional group and the treated group. Patients in the conventional group were given conventional treatment, while patients in the treated group were given conventional treatment and AI.
Measurement on the 1st and 14th day
|A. Cytokine - NA
B. Cell subset
CD3+, CD4+, CD4+/CD8+, CD16+, CD69+of the treated group, higher than those of conventional group (P<0.05); CD8+ lower than that of conventional group (P<0.05).
|36 Abdominal trauma patients|||
|(I) 1. Eleutherococcussenticosus||Treatmentgroup received 10 ml of ethanolic (vincamine free)
Eleutherococcussenticosus preparation, 3 times daily for 4 weeks, in comparison with placebo ethanolic group
|Placebo-controlled, double-blinded study||A. Cytokine – NA
B. Cell subset
Significant increase in absolute number of total lymphocyte (p<0.0001)
Pronounced effect on T-helper (p<0.00001) and T-suppressor cells (p<0,0001), NK cells(p<0.01) and B-lymphocyte (p<0.05)
|(36 healthy subjects)|||
|2.Eleutherococcussenticosus||33% ethanolic extract (8 mL/day) containing either ES, PG (equivalent to 4 g/day and 2 g/day of dried root||A. Cytokine - NA
B. Cell subset
No significant change for total T cells, T helper cells (CD4), T suppressor cells (CD8), CD4 to CD8 ratio, NK cells, and B lymphocytes
CD: Cluster of differentiation; ES: Eleutherococcus senticosus; IFN: Interferon; IL: Interleukin; NA: Not applicable; NK: Natural killer; PBL: Peripheral blood lymphocytes; PG: Panax ginseng; TNF: Tumor necrosis factor.
Table 1: Effect of medicinal mushrooms or herbs on selected clinical trials.
Medicinal mushroom Coriolus versicolor also known as Trametes versicolor is classified as Basidiomycetes macrofungi class consisting of over 22,000 species. It is called “Yun Zhi” in China meaning of “cloud-like-mushroom”. Its record of application in China can be traced back to The Compendium of Materia Medica written by Li Shizhen during the Ming Dynasty with over 120 strains. There are two well-known commercial preparations of polysaccharide of Coriolus versicolor -- polysaccharide peptide (PSP, produced in China) and polysaccharide Krestin (PSK, produced in Japan).
Coriolus versicolor has been extensively investigated in phase I, II and III randomized clinical trials in esophageal, breast, colorectal and stomach cancer patients in Asia . Since 1970, many large scale clinical research studies have been conducted mainly in Japan. Among the 35 randomized controlled trials on Coriolus versicolor conducted in Asia, more than half of these were of gastric cancer (n=19) and with 13,498 patients participated [28-45]. A quarter of the studies were of colorectal cancer (n=9) and with 2,194 patients involved [29,46-54]. Only a few clinical trials on esophageal (n=3) [55-57] and breast cancer (n=4) [58-61] with 532 patients and 2,217 patients respectively.
Most of the above-mentioned clinical research studies focus on the adjuvant therapy of Coriolus versicolor in combination with conventional drug on disease-free survival and overall survival rates. The adjuvant chemotherapy improved the 15- year survival rate for patients following curative resection. The overall survival durations for cancer patients have been shown to be significantly longer with Coriolus versicolor as the supplement for chemotherapy. These reviews concluded that PSK exert definite beneficial effects on esophageal, breast, colorectal and stomach cancer patients [32,46,59,62]. However, these reviews did not describe the effects on immunological markers profiles. A review of the original clinical trial research papers mentioned in the above-mentioned meta-analysis articles revealed some useful papers that have documented the patients’ immunological changes accompanying the improvement of the tumor responses and overall patients’ survival.
One of the key immunological effects of Coriolus versicolor is activation of blood NK cells. For instance, the group of Sadahiro et al. conducted a randomized trial of 30 cancer patients with adenocarcinoma of middle or lower rectum (CT3/CT4). Patients were randomized into the control group (n=15) and the PSK (Polysaccharide-Krestin, protein-bound polysaccharide) group (n=15). Both groups received two weeks’ chemoradiotherapy and four weeks’ S-1 administration (Taiho Pharmaceutical Co., Japan) 80 mg/m2/day divided into two daily doses before surgery (control group). The PSK group was treated the same chemo radiotherapy with simultaneous four weeks’ PSK administration PSK (Kureha Corporation, Japan) 3 g/day divided into three daily doses, for four weeks. It was found that PSK group has a significant increase of NK cells by 5% in the peripheral blood (P=0.003) . Furthermore, CD8 cytotoxic T cell counts increased by 153% (P=0.005) and 151% in the peri-tumoral and normal mucosa (p=0.003) respectively. The researchers therefore concluded that PSK may upregulate both the innate and humoral responses.
Another immune cell type that PSK has shown to have regulatory effect is a T cell subset of that expresses the NK marker CD57. The significance of these CD57+ T cells has been shown in an initial study of 48 patients with advanced-stage gastric carcinoma (stage III-IV, n2, and T3-4) such that patients with a higher proportion of CD57+ T cells (≥ 18%) was associated with poorer survival compared with the group of lower CD57+ T cells (<18%) (p=0.046) . The researchers proposed that in patients with advanced carcinomas (stage III-IV), but not the early cancer stages (stage I-II), the proportion of CD57+ T cells was able to predict patients with a poorer prognosis. Akagi and Baba  then reported a clinical trial with 21 patients randomly assigned to receive either 3 g PSK plus 300 mg tegafur/uracil (PSK group) or 300 mg tegafur/ uracil alone (control) orally each day for at least 1 year after operation. The 3-year overall survival was 62.2% in the PSK group and 12.5% in the control group. This survival advantage in the PSK group was correlated with decreased CD57+ T cells decreased compared to the control (p<0.0486).
Not all reported studies in Coriolus versicolor used the processed PSK products. Torkelson et al.  launched a phase 1 clinical trial of Coriolus versicolor in 11 women with breast cancer by oral treatment of Coriolus versicolor freeze-dried mycelial powder. Each capsule contained 500 mg of product with each cohort comprised of three participants given one of three doses of Coriolus vesicolor (3, 6 or 9 g). For the 9 women completed study, lymphocyte counts were observed to increase at 6 g/day and 9 g/day. NK cell functional activity measured by the number of effector cells (NK) required to achieve 20% specific lyses on the target cells (K562) was found to increase at 6 g/day. Dose-related increases in CD8+ T cells and CD19+ B cells but not CD4+ T cells or CD16+56+ NK cells were also reported. It is to be noted that with such small number of patients participated in the study, the results were not statistically significant.
In summary, the use of Coriolus versicolor, in either the processed form of PSK or the freeze dried mycelial powder of the medicinal mushroom has shown to be related to increase of both the numbers and functional activities of the blood NK cells.
Clinical trials on the medicinal mushroom Ganoderma lucidum have been conducted on healthy subjects and cancer patients using extracts from the spores or fruiting bodies or a combination of these. A few reports have used Ganopoly which is the aqueous polysaccharides fraction extracted from Ganoderma lucidum . It was prepared from the fruiting bodies of wood-cultured Ganoderma lucidum which were collected from southern China. The polysaccharides were consisted of 61.2% glucose, 15.5% xylose, 14.4% fructose, 4.8% galactose and 4.1% rhamnose and were linked together by β-glycosidic linkages. The concentration of proteins was 0.35% . The polysaccharide extracts were dark red powder packed as capsules by Alpha Pharmaceuticals of New Zealand according to GMP standard. The total dose is equivalent to 270 g fruiting body of Ganoderma lucidum .
Two clinical trials have been reported using this Ganopoly extract. The first clinical trial. was a non-randomized, non-placebo trial comparing with baseline treatment of 1,800 mg Ganopoly, three times daily orally before meals for 12 weeks on 34 advanced-stage cancer patients with diverse cancer origins including lung, colon, breast, liver, prostate, bladder, and brain . Examination of the serum cytokines of 30 patients assessed for immune function after 12 weeks revealed significant increased IL-2, IL-6 and IFN-ÃÂ¤ and also significant decreased IL-1 and TNF-α levels. The mean absolute number of CD56+ cells and NK cell activity were also significantly increased.
Another follow-up randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, multi-centre clinical trial from the same research group focusing on advanced-stage III to IV lung cancer patients applied the same protocol of 12 weeks of treatment with the same oral Ganopoly or placebo at a dose of three capsules (600 mg × 3=1800 mg) 3 times daily before meal . Total dose of 5,400 mg of Ganopoly per day was equivalent to 270 g fruiting body of Ganoderma lucidum . In this study, 68 lung cancer patients of were recruited and randomized into Ganopoly group of 37 patients and placebo group of 31 patients. For the Ganopoly treatment group of 32 patients assessable at the end of 12 weeks treatment, CD3 percentage and NK cell activity were significantly increased whereas the other parameters were no significant changes . Chen et al.  initiated a non-randomized open-labeled study on oral treatment of water-soluble Ganoderma lucidum polysaccharides with 1,800 mg three times daily of Ganoderma lucidum 5,400 mg/day was equivalent to 81 g fruiting body before meals for 12 weeks. In this study, 47 patients of advanced-stage III to IV colorectal cancer were recruited but only 41 patients assessable in the final measurement. For serum cytokine study, there was a trend of increase of cytokines of IL-2, IL-6 and IFN-ÃÂ¤ by 0.2%, 6.3% and 8.8% but did not reach statistical significance. There was also a trend of IL-1 and TNF-α decrease by 9.6% and 8.7% but again with no statistical significance. In the same study, the number of CD3, CD4, CD8 and CD56 lymphocytes also showed a trend of increase. Similarly the NK cells activity was found to be increased but did not achieve statistical significance. This reflects the requirement of bigger numbers of the patient pool in the immunological studies to overcome the diverse difference in the baseline values of various immunological parameters and diverse responses to the specific herbal medicines.
Zhang et al.  conducted a study on 40 male football players. Three groups labeled as LHTL1, LHTL2 and LHTL3 groups were provided with placebo, Ganoderma lucidum ten capsules (2.5 g/day) and Ganoderma lucidum 20 capsules (5 g/day) for six weeks (two weeks baseline supplementation followed by 28 days of the treatment protocol). These Ganoderma lucidum capsules contained total extract isolated from the fruiting body of Ganoderma lucidum by boiling water and mixed with pure pores at a ratio of 7:2. LHTL3 group (5 g/day) was found increased significantly the percentage of CD3+, CD4+ cells compared with the LHTL1 placebo group.
Zhao et al.  investigated the effects of spore powder of Ganoderma lucidum containing polysaccharides, triterpenoids, alkaloids, enzymes and proteins at 1,000 mg three times a day for four weeks on breast cancer patients by a randomized, placebo controlled trial. 48 breast cancer patients of stage I to IIIA were selected for the study. Cytokine levels of TNF-α and IL-6 were found to be significantly lowered. The mean serum TNF-α levels at pre- and post-treatment in the Ganoderma group were detected as 128.7 pg/mL and 71.9 pg/mL respectively. Similarly, the mean serum levels of IL-6 pre- and post-treatment in the Ganoderma group were found to be 62.4 pg/mL and 37.6 pg/mL respectively.
A randomized, double-blind, cross-over trial with placebocontrolled run-in and cross-over periods on 26 patients with hypertension and or dyslipidemia was conducted by Chu et al. . Treatment of 12 weeks was each on Ganoderma lucidum treatment or on matching placebo. The dosage was 1.44 g extract taken with two capsules (each capsule contains 360 mg extract) twice daily, which was equivalent to 13.2 g of the fresh mushroom (recommended dose of Ganoderma lucidum in the Chinese Materia Medica of 11.25-18.75 g of fresh material). In this study, 26 patients with hypertension and or dyslipidemia were recruited with final 23 evaluable subjects. Both the cell counts and percentages of the B lymphocytes and T helper cell were found decreased during the Ganoderma lucidum treatment but the changes were not significantly different from those of the placebo treatment.
Wachtel-Galor et al. conducted a double-blinded, placebocontrolled and cross-over intervention study on 18 healthy subjects of aged 22-52 years were enrolled for four weeks supplementation with a commercially available encapsulated Ganoderma lucidum preparation (1.44 g Ganoderma lucidum per day equivalent to 13.2 g fresh mushroom per day) . The mean CD4:CD8 ratio for the placebo group was 1.6 on Day 1 and 1.5 on Day 29 whereas that for the Ganoderma lucidum group was 1.5 on Day 1 and 1.6 on Day 29. As the mean CD4:CD8 ratio was more or less the same between the Ganoderma lucidum treatment group and placebo group, it led to achieving no statistical significance. Both the innate and humoral responses were not enhanced in these healthy subjects.
A double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trial on 16 cancer patients was led by Wicks et al.  in 2007. In this study, 2 g of the Ganoderma lucidum extract contained 1.89% of terpenoids and 15.8% of polysaccharides or placebo treatment twice daily for ten consecutive days. Oral doses of Ganoderma lucidum extract or placebo were four capsules each time. 16 normal subjects with eight male and eight non-pregnant female were also included in the study. A short-term increase of CD56 NK cells that sustained for only ten days after intake of Ganoderma lucidum extract was found. The CD4, CD8, CD19 cell counts were demonstrated with no obvious change. All these results were not statistically significant.
In summary for Ganoderma lucidum immunological effect, both the NK cell number and activity were significantly increased. The levels of serum cytokines of IL-2, IL-6 and IFN-ÃÂ¤ were found to be significantly increased. It is to be noted that these cytokines can stimulate in turn an array of immunological important cell types of T cells, B cells and dendritic cells. On the other hand, the inflammatory cytokines of IL-1 and TNF-α were found to be significantly decreased with the use of Ganoderma lucidum .
Ding et al.  investigated the efficacy of Cordyceps sinensis (CS) in long term treatment of renal transplant patients. The renal function and survival rates of grafts and patients did not show significantly difference between the control group and the treatment group. However, the incidences of complications were significantly lower in the treatment group compared with that in control group with the exception of those showing acute rejection. It was reported that the serum level of IL-10 in the treatment group was significantly higher than that in control group. However, there was no significant difference in the serum level of IL-2 in these two groups. These data demonstrated that CS might be used in combination with a low dose of CsA in the long term treatment of kidney transplant patients. This result was agreed by another evidence-based systematic review stating that Ding’s group finding of Cordyceps in combination with low dose of cyclosporin A is effective as an immunosuppressant agent in the treatment of renal transplant patients .
An injection of astragalus extract called Milkvetch Injection (MI) was found to be useful at signiÃ¯Â¬Âcantly improving immune function in children after major surgery to correct tetralogy of Fallot compared to standard treatment . This study was to evaluate the effect of MI on immune function of children with tetralogy of Fallot after radical operation. In this study, 40 young patients were equally divided into two groups of 20. The control group was treated with conventional treatment alone and the other group received both conventional treatment and 15 ml of MI every 12 hours for 14 days.
In the MI-treated group, the abnormally increased levels of IgG, IgM, C3, C4, CD8+ cells and CD19+ cells began to lower at lst-2nd week after treatment, and basically restored to the levels of normal at the 3rd-4th week. In the same patient group, the original decreased levels of IgA, CD3+ cells, CD4+cells, CD4+/ CD8+ ratio, CD3+/HLA-DR+ cells and CD16+CD56+ cells at base line raised gradually from the 1st week and restored to normal range at 2nd-3rd week. The plasma IL-6 and tumor necrosis factoralpha (TNF-α) levels in the same MI-treated group were found to decrease gradually at the 1st week and restored to the normal level at the 3rd-4th weeks (p<0.05).
This same injection of Astragalus extract was reported to help restoring normal cellular immunity in patients who had suffered major abdominal trauma according to a clinical trial lead by Wu et al. in China . A total of 36 serious abdominal traumatic patients were randomly assigned into two groups, the control group and the MI-treated group, patients in the control group were given conventional treatment, while others in the treated group were given conventional treatment plus MI 20 mL injection mixed in 250 mL of 5% glucose solution given through intravenous dripping. T cell activated antigens of these two groups together with 10 healthy subjects were simultaneously monitored on the first day and the 14th day. On the first day, in the control group and MI-treated group, the cell counts of cells expressing the surface markers of CD3+, CD4+, CD4+/CD8+, CD16+, CD69+ and CD3+/ human HLA-DR+ were apparently lower than the healthy subjects (p<0.05), and there was no significant difference between the conventional group and the treated group (P>0.05). Then on the 14th days, the cell numbers of CD3+ CD4+ CD4+CD8+ CD16+ CD69+ and CD3+HLA-DR+ of the MI-treated group got closed to healthy subject value, and higher than those of conventional group (P<0.05). The researchers concluded that MI can enhance the cellular immunity aspect and confirmed the findings with further immunological and anti-tumor studies in vitro and in vivo [67,68].
A placebo-controlled, double-blinded study was conducted by Bohn et al.  to investigate the immunological effects of an Eleutherococcus senticosus ethanolic extract (Eleukokk) in 36 healthy volunteers. The treatment group received 10 mL of Eleukokk, three times daily for four weeks, whereas for the placebo, the Eleutherococcus senticosus extract was substituted by additional wine, resulting in identical final concentrations of ethanol in both preparations. There was an increase of total lymphocyte (p<0.0001), in particularly the CD4+ T helper cells (p<0.00001), but also on CD8+ T suppressor cells (P<0.0001), and CD19+ B cells (p<0.05) compared with placebo. However, there was no significant difference in the change of NK cells.
Gaffney et al.  initiated a clinical trial was undertaken to investigate the effects of Eleutherococcus senticosus and Panax ginseng on competitive club-level endurance athletes engaged in their normal in-season training. Participants were matched for training stress and received a 33% ethanolic extract (8 mL/day) containing either Eleutherococcus senticosus, Panax ginseng (equivalent to 4 g and 2 g/day of dried root, respectively), or a placebo. A pre-test and post-test were used to evaluate the effects of six weeks of supplementation on cortisol, testosterone, and testosterone to cortisol ratio well as circulating numbers of total T cells, CD4+ T helper cells, CD8+ T suppressor cells, CD4/ CD8 ratio, CD16+CD56+NK cells, and CD19+ B cells. None of the immune system variables changed significantly nor showed any clear trend from pre- to post-test in any of the treatment groups. The only significant result was that for the Eleutherococcus group there was a decrease of the testosterone to cortisol ratio by 29% from 0.047 to 0.033. However, this study suffered from the drawback of incapable to distinguish the individual effect of Eleutherococcus senticosus and Panax ginseng.
In this review of the two mushrooms Coriolus versicolor and Ganoderma lucidum , the promising clinical effects are found to be related to a concurrent activation of some immune cell populations in particularly the NK cells. NK cell population can be regarded as the most important cell type for our innate immunity for the first line of defense against disease [69,70]. The major subset of (90%) the NK cells are equipped with strong cytolytic activities against target cells . However before these medicinal mushrooms can be considered as suitable future target therapeutic agents, more high-quality, long-term doubleblinded, placebo-controlled studies with large trial populations are definitely required.
This review also identified a clear research gap of the lack of laboratory investigation of the major immune cell population of Dendritic Cell (DC). DCs are competent professional antigen presenting cell to present the target antigens by first priming the naïve T cells [72,73] to initiate both the antigen-specific B and T cell responses. Essentially the DC, B cells and T cells as a triad constitutes the adaptive immunity. Furthermore, there are at least 5 different DC subsets in human blood . Therefore future clinical trials of these potentially clinical useful medicinal mushrooms and herbs should also focus at the blood DC and its various subsets in blood to provide a more comprehensive multidirectional network of mechanisms of action
All Published work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved. iMedPub LTD Last revised : September 21, 2019