Ambrose Antony Kiang’u Ghwanga and Musa Chacha*
School of Life Sciences and Bio-Engineering, Nelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology, Arusha, Tanzania
Received Date: February 01, 2019; Accepted Date: February 21, 2019; Published Date: March 02, 2019
Citation: Ghwanga AAK, Chacha M (2019) In Vitro Antimicrobial Activity of Conyza bonariensis and Tribulus terrestris Growing in Tanzania. Herb Med Vol.5 No.1:4. doi: 10.21767/2472-0151.100042
Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate antimicrobial activity of Conyza bonariensis and Tribulus terrestris growing in Tanzania. Background statement: The improvement of antimicrobial agents has protected and improved human life from fatal diseases since their discovery. The increase in microbial drug resistance demands for new effective drugs of which medicinal plants are a promising source. Methods: Minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) in 96- well micro dilution was used to determine antimicrobial activity. The method involved loading of 50 μL of Sabouraud’s dextrose broth in each well. Then, 50 μL of plant extract fetched from 100 mg/mL stock solution to form 100 μL. Thereafter, 50 μL of the mixture from the first rows was repeatedly down the columns until the last row where 50 μL were discarded. Subsequently, 50 μl of microbial suspensions was added in each well and incubated at 37°C for 24 hours. In each well, 20 μL of 0.02% Para-iodonitrotetrazolium chloride dye (INT) was added to micro plates in order to distinguish between the wells with live microbes from those with dead microbes. Results: All extracts demonstrated antimicrobial activity to tested bacterial and fungal strains. Seven extracts namely C. bonariensis leaf chloroform, C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate, C. bonariensis stem chloroform, C. bonariensis stem ethyl acetate, C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate, T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate inhibited Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Salmonella typhimurium, Salmonella typhi and Cryptococcus neoformans at 0.78125 mg/mL. Plant extracts demonstrated synergistic effect of their chemical components against the tested microbes. The strongest bactericidal and fungicidal of combined extracts was exhibited on E. coli and C. neoformans respectively. The extracts from C. albicans and T. terrestris revealed antimicrobial activity against seven tested microbes. Conclusion: It was concluded that C. bonariensis and T. terrestris can be considered as possible sources of antimicrobial drug leads upon further phytochemical investigations.
Antimicrobial; Conyza bonariensis; Tribulus terrestris; Extract; MIC; Synergistic effect; Ethno-medical information
Humans have used antibiotics to manage bacterial and fungal infections for the last seven decades . Infectious diseases killed 3.25 million of children worldwide in the year 2013  and bacterial infections accounted for 17.8% global human death . The situation is worse in developing countries that may have been attributed by poor medication and little or non-affordability of proper antimicrobial drug. The prevalence of infectious diseases is high despite the availability of conventional antimicrobial drugs mainly because some microbes have acquired resistance to the present drugs .
In these circumstances, the search for effective, safe and affordable antimicrobial drugs is an appealing need. Ethnomedical information has gained popularity as one of reliable sources for drug templates . It is estimated that about 25% of conventional drugs originate from medicinal plants .
It is further reported that about 56% of people in Kilimanjaro region use traditional medicines in their primary health care . Tanzania is estimated to have about 1,000 medicinal plant species . Despite the fact that the country is blessed with high diversity of medicinal plants, only few of them have been evaluated for their antimicrobial activity.
Conyza bonariensis is an annual herb present all over the world except in Antarctica [8,9]. It is used for treatment of ailment such as sore throat, ringworm, chicken pox, bleeding from injuries, toothache diarrhea and constipation in Pakistan and China [10,11]. In Tanzania, C. bonariensis is used for treatment of HIV/AIDS opportunistic infections . Tribulus terrestris which is commonly known as spine/puncher vine is distributed in tropical, subtropical and warm temperate areas . Leaves of the T. terrestris are used traditionally to treat gonorrhea, inflammation, leprosy, skin diseases, ulitis, and general body weakness at Gujarat region in India . Traditionally, this herb is used to enhance libido, stimulate spermatogenesis, vermifuge and medicine to skin diseases [12,15].
Fungal and bacterial infections continue to cost the wellbeing of humans because, some pathogenic bacteria and fungi have acquired adaptive mechanisms to present antibacterial and antifungal drugs respectively . Furthermore, the problem continues to cost peoples’ life because of insufficient efforts to search for new and effective antimicrobial drugs. Although currently medicinal plants have been regarded as promising source of antimicrobial drugs, most of them have not been scientifically evaluated to be considered in drug production .
In searching for new antimicrobial drugs, in vitro evaluation of unstudied medicinal plants is essential at initial stages. That is why this study reports the antifungal and antibacterial activity on C. bonariensis and T. terrestris growing in Tanzania on four Gram-negative bacteria which are Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Salmonella typhi, Salmonella typhimurium, one Gram-positive Methelin-resistant bacterium Staphylococcus aureus as well as two fungal strains namely Cryptococcus neoformans and Candida albicans.
Acquisition of materials
Distilled water was collected from Arusha Technical College while seawater from Indian Ocean along the Dar es Salaam coast. Para-iodonitrotetrazolium chloride dye (INT) and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) were purchased from Sigma and Alrich, St Louis, USA. Ketoconazole was purchased from S Kant Healthcare LTD, Gujarat, India and Ciprofloxacin tablets were bought from Micro Lab LTD, India. Chloroform, ethyl acetate and methanol were purchased from Avantor performance materials in India. Both nutrient (agar and broth), Sabouraud‘s dextrose (agar and broth) were purchased from Hi Media Laboratories Pvt Ltd (Mumbai-India).
Selection of microorganisms for testing the potency of medicinal plants depended on the availability during the study on their pathogenic representativeness as suggested by Cos et al. . The test microorganisms were two fungal strains namely Cryptococcus neoformans (clinical isolate) and Candida albicans (ATCC 90028), one Gram-positive bacterium Staphylococcus aureus (ATCC29213) and four Gram-negative bacteria namely Escherichia coli (ATCC25922), Pseudomonas aeruginosa (ATCC 29953), Salmonella typhi (ATCC 6539) and Salmonella typhimurium (ATCC 14023) were obtained from the Department of Microbiology, Muhimbili University of Health and Allied Sciences (MUHAS).
Leaves, stem bark and roots of C. bonariensis and T. terrestris were collected from Nambala, Themi and Kaloleni areas in Arusha. Plant species were identified by Mr. Mboya from Tropical Pesticides Research Institute (TPRI) and voucher specimens AMB501 and AMB502 were are assigned for C. bonariensis and T. terrestris respectively. The leaves, stem barks and roots of C. bonariensis and T. terrestris were harvested while observing the sustainability of the plants.
The collected plant materials were washed thoroughly with tape water, dried in shade and pulverized with electrical grinder to form fine powders to increase surface area for extraction. From each of the plant material, 350 g of the powder was sequentially macerated twice by being completely immersed in 99.8% chloroform, 99.5% ethyl acetate and 99.5% methanol solvents for 48 hours at room temperature. All extracts were stored in the refrigerator at -20°C until the time of conducting bioassay experiments.
Minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) of the extracts against bacteria and fungi was determined through micro dilution method using 96-well plates as proposed by Eloff  with minor modifications. Firstly, 100 mg of each plant extract was dissolved in 1 ml of DMSO to form 100 mg/mL stock solutions. In testing extracts’ synergistic effect, 50 mg of one plant extract and the same amount of the other extract were mixed in a 1:1 ratio and then dissolved into 1 ml of DMSO to form 100 mg/mL stock solutions.
A 50 μL of Sabouraud’s dextrose broth was loaded into sterilized 96-well microtitre plates followed by addition of 50 μl of 100 mg/mL extract in first well of each row to make a total volume of 100 μl in each of the first-row wells. The plant extracts and Sabouraud’s dextrose broth were thoroughly mixed in the first rows. After that, 50 μl of the mixture from the first rows was shifted to the second rows and shifting continued down the columns until the last row where 50 μl from each well was discarded.
Next, 50 μl of microbial suspensions (0.5 MacFarland) were added in each well and incubated at 37°C for 24 hours followed by 20 μl of 0.02% p-iodonitrotetrazolium (INT) chloride dye and incubated for 1-hour at 37°C. Ketoconazole (100 μg/mL) and Ciprofloxacin were used as positive control for fungal and bacterial tests respectively. Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) and the row which contained only broth were used as growth control representing negative control.
The change in the color of INT was observed where formation of pink indicated live microbes and persistence of the color of INT meant the microbes were dead. Even though 100% DMSO prohibits C. albicans growth, it has no effect in determining MIC because INT only causes color change to living organisms . The lowest concentration of the extracts that killed or did not allow the survival of microbes was described as Minimum Inhibitory Concentration (MIC) that is the lowest effective dose against the tested organism.
Results emanated from antimicrobial evaluation of Conyza bonariensis and Tribulus terrestris extracts are summarized in Table 1. The extracts were tested against four Gram-negative and one Gram-positive bacteria and two fungal strains and all the microbes are pathogenic to human being. The minimum inhibitory concentration (MIC) shows the activity of the extract against the microbes as presented in Tables 1 and 2. Eighty percent of the tested bacteria and 50% of the tested fungi were inhibited by the extracts at the MIC value of 0.78125 mg/mL.
|Plant Extracts||Minimum Inhibition Concentration (mg/mL)|
|E. coli||S. typhimurium||S. aureus||S. typhi||P. aeruginosa||C. albicans||C. neoformans||S.E|
Key: CLC-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform, CLE-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate, CLM-C. bonariensis leaf methanol, CSC-C. bonariensis stem chloroform, CSE-C. bonariensis stem ethyl acetate, CSM-C. bonariensis stem methanol, CRC-C. bonariensis root chloroform, CBRE-C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate, CRM-C. bonariensis root methanol, TLC-T. terrestris leaf chloroform, TLE-T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate, TLM-T. terrestris leaf methanol, TSC-T. terrestris stem chloroform, TSE-T. terrestris stem ethyl acetate, TSM-T. terrestris stem methanol, Keto-Ketoconazole, Cipr-Ciprofloxacin, S.E-Standard error.
Table 1: Antimicrobial activities of C. bonariensis and T. terrestris (leaf, stem and root bark).
|Combined Plant Extracts||Minimum inhibition concentration (mg/mL)|
|E. coli||S. typhimurium||S. aureus||S. typhi||P. aeruginosa||C. albicans||C. neoformans||S. E|
Key: CLCCLE-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate, CLCCLM-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and C. bonariensis leaf ethyl methanol, CLCCRC-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and C. bonariensis root chloroform, CLCCRE-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate, CLCCRM-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and C. bonariensis root methanol, CLECRC-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and C. bonariensis root chloroform, CLECLM-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and C. bonariensis leaf methanol, CLECRE-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate, CLECRM-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and C. bonariensis root methanol, CLMCRC-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and C. bonariensis root chloroform, CLMCRE-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate, CLMCRM-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and C. bonariensis root methanol, CLCTLC-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and T. terrestris leaf chloroform, CLCTLE-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate, CLCTLM-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and T. terrestris leaf methanol, CLETLC-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris leaf chloroform, CLETLE-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate, CLETLM-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris leaf methanol, CLMTLC-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and T. terrestris leaf chloroform, CLMTLE-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate, CLMTLM-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and T. terrestris leaf methanol, CLCTRC-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and T. terrestris root chloroform, CLCTRE-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate, CLCTRM-C. bonariensis leaf chloroform and T. terrestris root methanol, CLETRC-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root chloroform, CLETRE-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate, CLETRM-C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root methanol, CLMTRC-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and T. terrestris root chloroform, CLMTRE-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate, CLMTRM-C. bonariensis leaf methanol and T. terrestris root methanol, TLCTLE-T. terrestris leaf chloroform and T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate, TLCTLM-T. terrestris leaf chloroform and T. terrestris leaf methanol, TLETLM-T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris leaf methanol, TLETRC-T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root chloroform, TLETRE-T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate, TLETRM-T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root methanol, TRCTRE-T. terrestris root chloroform and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate, TRETRM-T. terrestris root ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root methanol, TLMTRC-T. terrestris leaf methanol and T. terrestris root chloroform, TLMTRE-T. terrestris leaf methanol and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate, TLMTRM-T. terrestris leaf methanol and T. terrestris root methanol, S.E-Standard error.
Table 2: Antimicrobial activities of mixed extracts from C. bonariensis and T. terrestris (leaf and root extracts).
According to Rios and Recio , plant extracts that are suggested in the drug discovery initiatives are the ones with MIC values less than 1 mg/mL. In this study, C. bonariensis leaf chloroform (CLC), C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate (CLE), C. bonariensis stem chloroform (CSC), C. bonariensis stem ethyl acetate (CSE), C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate (CRE), T. terrestris leaf ethyl acetate (TLE) and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate (TRE) met that criterion. They exhibited MIC value of 0.78125 mg/mL against S. aureus, P. aeruginosa, C. neoformans, S. typhimurium and S. typhi (Table 1).
Apparently, C. albicans and E. coli were the least susceptible to the tested extracts in which none of the extracts exhibited their growth at MIC value of 0.78125 mg/mL. Two extracts, namely CLE and CRE inhibited C. albicans at MIC value 1.5625 mg/mL while CLE and C. bonariensis root chloroform (CRC) inhibited E. coli at the same concentration.
It was noted that, 75% of extracts with MIC values below 1 mg/mL emanated from C. bonariensis extracts and 25% from T. terrestris extracts. This means C. bonariensis is preferably a more promising source for antimicrobial agents than T. terrestris. The lethality of phytochemicals contained in extracts was specific to the tested pathogens. The type of solvent used in extraction appeared to influence antimicrobial activity of the extracts. In a total of seven 0.78125 mg/mL MIC value, five of them were ethyl acetate extracts, two chloroform extracts and none methanol extracts.
Some phytochemicals demonstrate more pharmacokinetic when in combination with other relevant compounds than when in isolation .
In light of that, the synergistic effect of phytochemicals from different plant extracts were examined. The findings of the investigation demonstrated the presence of antimicrobial synergistic effect in the combined extracts which was evidenced by increasing antimicrobial efficacy of extracts. Microbial susceptibility to phytochemicals in combined extracts was determined to be species specific. Escherichia coli that was the most resistant bacterium in uncombined extracts became the most susceptible to mixed extracts. This was attributed by the observation that 32% of extracts’ combinations were effective against E. coli at MIC values of 0.78125 mg/mL and 0.390625 mg/mL. The strongest synergistic effect came from CLC (6.25 mg/mL)-CLE (1.5625 mg/mL) and CLC (6.25 mg/mL)-CRE (6.25 mg/mL) combinations which inhibited the growth of E. coli at MIC values of 0.390625 mg/mL. Combinations CLC (06.25 mg/mL)- CRC (1.5625 mg/mL); CLE (1.5625 mg/mL)-CRM (6.25 mg/mL); CLE (1.5625 mg/mL)-CRM (6.25 mg/mL); CLC (6.25 mg/mL)- TLC (3.125 mg/mL); CLE (1.5625 mg/mL)-TLE (3.125 mg/mL); CLC (6.25 mg/mL)-TRM (3.125 mg/mL) and CLE (1.5625 mg/ mL)-TRC (12.5 mg/mL) inhibited the growth of E. coli at MIC value 0.7825 mg/mL. Other combinations which inhibited the growth of E. coli at 0.7825 mg/mL MIC value to attest antimicrobial synergism of their phytochemicals were CLM (3.125 mg/mL)-TRE (6.25 mg/mL); TLC (3.125 mg/mL)-TLE (3.125 mg/mL); TLE (3.125 mg/mL)-TRC (12.5 mg/mL); TLE (3.125 mg/mL)-TRM (3.125 mg/mL); and TRC (12.5 mg/mL)- TRE (6.25 mg/mL).
Extract combinations of CLE (3.125 mg/mL)-CRE (1.5625 mg/mL); CLE (3.125 mg/mL)-TLM (12.5 mg/mL); CLM (1.5625 mg/mL)-TLC (12.5 mg/mL); CLM (1.5625 mg/mL)-TRC (12.5 mg/mL); CLM (1.5625 mg/mL)-TRE (3.125 mg/mL); TLC (12.5 mg/mL)-TLE (6.25 mg/mL) and TRC (12.5 mg/mL)-TRE (3.125 mg/mL) had strong antibacterial activity of 0.7825 mg/mL values against S. typhimurium.
Seven percent of the 41 extract combinations namely CLE (1.5625 mg/mL)-TRM (1.5625 mg/mL); CLM (3.125 mg/mL)- TRM (1.5625 mg/mL) and TLE (3.125 mg/mL)-TRM (1.5625 mg/mL) demonstrated antibacterial synergistic effect against S. aureus which was revealed lowered MIC values to 0.78125 mg/m. For the case of S. typhi, 4 out of 41 extract combinations had lower MIC values than before they were mixed. These combinations were (6.25 mg/mL)-CRC (3.125 mg/mL); CLE (6.25 mg/mL)-TLC (6.25 mg/mL) and CLE (6.25 mg/mL)-TRC (6.25 mg/mL) to 0.78125 mg/mL. However, extract combination CLC (3.125 mg/mL)-TLC (6.25 mg/mL) produced the strongest synergistic effect against S. typhi that lowed the MIC values to 0.390625 mg/mL. Extracts did not show remarkable synergistic effect against Pseudomonas aeruginosa bacterium.
The fungus C. neoformans was more susceptible to phytochemical synergistic effect than C. albicans. The extracts’ combinations CLE (1.5625 mg/mL)-CRC (6.25 mg/mL) and CLE (6.25 mg/mL)-TLE (6.25 mg/mL) showed strong antifungal activity to C. albicans at MIC value of 0.78125 mg/mL while combinations CLC (3.125 mg/mL) CLM (3.125 mg/mL); CLE (3.125 mg/mL)-TLC (6.25 mg/mL); CLC (3.125 mg/mL)-TRM (12.5 mg/mL); CLE (3.125 mg/mL)-TRM (12.5 mg/mL); and CLM (3.125 mg/mL)-TRM (12.5 mg/mL) had strong antifungal activity to C. neoformans at MIC value of 0.78125 mg/mL.
Evaluation of traditional medicine has been a reliable approach in drug discovery process . However, the medicinal efficacy of some traditionally used medicinal plants have not been validated. In light of that fact, this study is reporting for the first time the antibacterial and antifungal activity of C. bonariensis and T. terrestris growing in Arusha region of Tanzania. According to Eloff , extracts with MIC values 0.05-0.5 mg/mL, 0.6-1.5 mg/mL and above 1.5 mg/mL represented strong, moderate and weak antimicrobial activity respectively. According to Rios and Recio , plant extracts which should be considered in drug discovery enterprises are the ones with MIC values less than 1 mg/mL. Extracts which displayed antifungal and antibacterial activity with MIC values 0.78125 and 0.39065 mg/mL were qualified for further examination as foundations of drug leads.
In this aspect, C. bonariensis leaf chloroform, C. bonariensis stem ethyl acetate, C. bonariensis root ethyl acetate, C. bonariensis leaf ethyl acetate, T terrestris leaf ethyl acetate and T. terrestris root ethyl acetate demonstrated antibacterial against S. aureus, S. typhimurium, S. typhi and P. aeruginosa with MIC of 0.78125 mg/mL are possible antibiotic templates for the diseases caused by these bacteria. Similarly, C. bonariensis stem chloroform extract inhibited C. neoformans with MIC of 0.78125 mg/mL qualify to be a possible antifungal drug lead for treatment of C. neoformans caused infections.
According to Uzun et al.,  antimicrobial synergistic effect of phytochemicals occurs when different extracts are combined. Phytochemicals in C. bonariensis extracts produced synergistic effect against tested bacteria when combined with synthetic antibiotics . The findings showed that E. coli was selectively more prone to combined extracts than rest of tested bacteria. The bacteria was resistant to all extracts at MIC values below 1 mg/mL. However, the bacterium was sensitive to about 32% of extracts’ combinations. The fungus, C. albicans which initially was not inhibited by extracts before they were mixed, became susceptible to CBLE-CBRC and CBLE-TTLC extract combinations at MIC value of 0.78125 mg/mL. The effect of antimicrobial synergism of phytochemicals suggest that formulations of antimicrobial drugs should involve antimicrobial agents from different sources and extracted from different solvents. For better extraction, the type of solvent used, method of extraction and specifics during collection of materials have effects on results of antimicrobial activity of the extracts and should be valued .
The antimicrobial activity of C. bonariensis has been investigated in different parts of the world. Conyza bonariensis which is used to manage HIV/AIDS opportunistic infections in Tanzania and Uganda [24,25] possess antimicrobial activity. In Pakistan, the methanol and ethyl acetate extracts failed to inhibit the growth of C. albicans, E. coli, S. aureus and S. typhimurium at the MIC of 20 mg/mL . However, the same study revealed that methanolic and ethyl acetate extracts from C. bonariensis inhibited P. aeruginosa and Staphylococcus epidermidis at 13.3 mg/mL and 16 mg/mL respectively . Another study in Yemen discovered the antibacterial activity of C. bonariensis ethanol extracts against S. aureus, E. coli and S. typhimurium bacteria whereas S. aureus was mostly inhibited by extracts like in this study . Furthermore, essential oil from Kenyan C. bonariensis exhibited antibacterial activity against two Gram-negative bacterial strains namely E. coli and S. typhi . They found that, S. typhi was also more vulnerable than E. coli to C. bonariensis extracts. Although not very much studied, the antimicrobial activity of T. terrestris have been reported . According to Hashim et al. , T. terrestris contain high amount of spirostanol saponins which inhibited fungal growth of C. albicans and C. neoformans. The antimicrobial activity of T. terrestris extracts are also in line with reported antifungal and antibacterial activity in Iran . However, unlike the findings from this study, the Pakistani T. terrestris showed no antibacterial activity against P. aeruginosa bacterium . The ethno-medical uses of C. bonariensis and T. terrestris in management of bacterial and fungal infections are endorsed by the findings of this study. The medicinal value of T. terrestris is highly associated with its high content of saponins which its composition varies due to geographical locations .
The extracts from C. albicans and T. terrestris revealed antifungal two fungal strains namely C. neoformans and C. albicans. The extracts from the same plants also revealed antibacterial activities against four tested Gram-negative bacteria namely E. coli, S. typhimurium, S. typhi and P. aeruginosa and against one Methicillin- resistant Gram-positive bacterium namely S. aureus.
This study has publicized the antifungal and antibacterial activity of C. bonariensis and T. terrestris growing in Tanzania. It has further revealed the influence of phytochemicals’ synergistic effect in management of bacterial and fungal infections.
Authors declare that there is no competing interests exist.
Authors are grateful to Arusha Technical College for financial support and The Nelson Mandela African Institution of Science and Technology for hosting experimental work.